The Blog

  • January 18, 2006
  • AppExchange Debuts and Nothing Will Ever Be the Same

    I was the guy standing on the sidewalk the other day outside the hotel in San Francisco where was announcing the birth of AppExchange. You couldn’t miss me, I was the analyst with an empty Starbucks cup panhandling for new ideas.

    For the last two years I had been talking and writing about the importance of a new kind of on demand application platform that would enable users to have instant access to best of breed software that would integrate with whatever else they were using. Essentially, I had been talking about what AppExchange is and now that it had arrived I might have felt a little insecure about my future, hence the cup.

    Maybe that was just a bit overdone. After all, a product announcement is really just the end of the beginning, not the beginning of the end. If AppExchange is another disruptive innovation from — and I firmly believe it is — then there is a lot to look forward to. Consider these potential milestones.

    More platforms

    We saw the beginning of the platform wars the week before’s announcement when NetSuite announced availability of NetFlex. I have belabored the point elsewhere so I will only say that you can’t have a market with only one vendor, unless that market is sunsetting. So having two vendors in the space marks an official beginning in my mind.

    Other companies are gearing up to enter the space too and Rearden Commerce is a great example. Though Rearden is gaining lots of traction right now with its employee spending management application, the solution is really just the first application for their platform. To make an analogy it’s like saying CRM is’s first application on AppExchange. Other vendors are champing at the bit and some will announce this quarter though I am not free to identify them yet. In addition to general purpose platforms, I am also seeing evidence of specialty platforms surfacing in areas like on demand call center and on demand analytics.

    So, shortly we should see a proliferation of platforms and developers and users will weigh the pro’s and con’s of each. Platforms will replace conventional operating systems as the deployment and integration foundation and savvy developers will keep their applications vanilla to make them easier to deploy among platforms.

    Generating revenue

    At the same time, more work will need to be done by the platform vendors to make it easier for their partners to transact with customers. Currently, stands back from the transaction between its ecosystem partners and the end users. The company takes no percentage of the sale and its revenue comes from selling another hosting seat. In this there is a strong analogy with the Windows operating system. Every PC user buys a Windows license but Microsoft makes nothing on the applications that run in Windows and Microsoft stays out of the transaction.

    Theres nothing wrong with that model but I wouldn’t bet it represents a high watermark, here’s why. Microsoft doesn’t produce a catalog of Windows applications or assist in the sale, but does produce a catalog of AppExchange compatible applications. More than that, also provides the forum and virtually brings the customer to the vendor by placing AppExchange on its site. There’s no doubt that it is good business for to forego any immediate revenue for the sake of bringing people into the exchange and making it successful. But don’t expect this to remain standard procedure, at some point the partners will encourage to take a more active role in selling and take a percentage.

    The reason is pretty simple. AppExchange will make traditional software sales and marketing somewhat obsolete. There will still be a need for sales and marketing but not to the degreewe currently see it for the simple reason that vendors will decide they don’t need to pay as many sales people if customers do their own demos and call up with purchase orders. In such a case it will be less expensive for a vendor to pay a percentage of a deal to or whoever is the platform vendor than it will be to pay a dedicated sales force. That’s why the partners will encourage to take a percentage.

    Strength in numbers

    On related point, the danger for any software vendor is of having to settle for whatever terms the platform vendor dictates or risk being shut out of the market. That’s why there will be a market for multiple platforms and why software developers will support them. I think there will be compatibility issues between platforms just as there are now between operating system and database versions.

    Other issues

    There are more issues to consider but let me leave you with just one more and that’s application style. What I mean is that so far, most of what were seeing in AppExchange are traditional database applications — data is input and viewed through a UI and reports are generated. In his speech Marc Benioff made a big deal about "mashups" — applications that are constructed at the intersection of data from and Google Maps for instance. But mashups are simply an elaboration of the basic database application. There are other styles of application that the AppExchange is a good home for. Some are horizontal like Skype which demonstrated its ability to phone enable any AppExchange application, but some will be more vertical.

    More important, I believe there are additional applications that bring together more than two parties in collaborative business processes that probably have not been thought of yet. I think the real power of AppExchange will be in its ability to promote their development. That should keep us all pretty busy.

    Published: 18 years ago


    • February 7th, 2006 at 2:42 am    

      The Coming Business Model

      Actually, this post is about the coming business model that is already here. Denis Pombriant at Beagle Research gave some context to’s AppExchange launch last month that we found quite interesting. His belief is that platforms for develo…

    • January 19th, 2006 at 1:46 pm    

      Software Platforms

      Denis Pombriant of Beagle puts some really interesting context around the delivery of the AppExchange. The launch of the AppExchange (and NetSuite’s NetFlex platform), he feels, is a sign that precedes certain events. It means that platforms will now b…

    Speak Up

    You must be logged in to post a comment.